Have you had results with acetone. [ Archive] - GasSavers.org - Helping You Save at the Pump
View Full Version : Have you had results with acetone.
zpiloto
08-23-2006, 06:42 PM
Anyone who has used acetone mixture and has had success please list mixture, make and age of car.
omgwtfbyobbq
08-23-2006, 07:06 PM
Can't remember my mixture, pretty sure it was the suggested ratio. 1992 V6 auto Camry. I also had my coolant boil over for the first and only time.
tomauto
08-23-2006, 07:08 PM
I couldn't tell. The only difference was that it made my idle speed lower. No harm.
zpiloto
08-23-2006, 07:09 PM
Can't remember my mixture, pretty sure it was the suggested ratio. 1992 V6 auto Camry. I also had my coolant boil over for the first and only time.
Did you stop using it then? Also what kind of increase did you see before and after.
omgwtfbyobbq
08-23-2006, 07:27 PM
Yup, it was on a run up the Cajon pass, after that I refilled coolant and stoped using acetone, no more trouble for the rest of the summer. I saw a difference of 2-3mpg over my best trip mpg (~34mpg) up to that point. The trip was hwy with the same distance, same traffic, same weather, and 55mph cruise control. The only problem was I didn't get in enough runs to determine if it was a glitch or if the acetone actually doing something, I also had ~5 miles our of 50 that were street, which could've influenced the results. I've heard it leans out the engine, but that's just heresay until I brush up on my chem... You wouldn't happen to know if your oxygen sensor is titanium dioxide, or zirconium dioxide?
zpiloto
08-23-2006, 07:40 PM
Yup, it was on a run up the Cajon pass, after that I refilled coolant and stoped using acetone, no more trouble for the rest of the summer. I saw a difference of 2-3mpg over my best trip mpg (~34mpg) up to that point. The trip was hwy with the same distance, same traffic, same weather, and 55mph cruise control. The only problem was I didn't get in enough runs to determine if it was a glitch or if the acetone actually doing something, I also had ~5 miles our of 50 that were street, which could've influenced the results. I've heard it leans out the engine, but that's just heresay until I brush up on my chem... You wouldn't happen to know if your oxygen sensor is titanium dioxide, or zirconium dioxide?
No I don't. I think it's probably zirconium.
ZugyNA
08-23-2006, 07:54 PM
3 oz per 10 G...'87 300ZX na...around a 20% gain...but some part of this was due to easier driving.
kickflipjr
08-23-2006, 08:05 PM
It was inconclusive for me. without a scangauge It makes results very difficult.
scostanz
08-23-2006, 08:38 PM
I used it for a little more than a month last year which translates into about a 1000 miles and didn't see any change in FE before, during or after using the stuff.
-- Scott
JanGeo
08-23-2006, 08:40 PM
It matters that you got some good acetone and that you drive to save otherwise you dont' get an improvement - it allows you to get even better gas mileage with it that without it - it doesn't give you better gas mileage it allows you to get better mileage. I couldn't get past 46mpg until I used it now I get 50-55mpg.
kickflipjr
08-23-2006, 08:51 PM
Well I have lots left over. I will use it when I start driving 90-100% highway in a few days.
MetroMPG
08-24-2006, 09:45 AM
It matters that [...] you drive to save otherwise you dont' get an improvement
I'm calling bull on that one!
JanGeo
08-24-2006, 11:06 AM
I'm calling bull on that one!
Hey I get 32mpg if I drive 80 on the highway with acetone - it doesn't help when you are burning it at 2.5 gallons an hour - it helps when you are burning 0.3 to 0.5 gallons per hour by making the injectors work better at low volume operation when they usually don't atomize the fuel properly.
zpiloto
08-24-2006, 11:22 AM
3 oz per 10 G...'87 300ZX na...around a 20% gain...but some part of this was due to easier driving.
So how much would you quantify to easier driving and have you stopped using it since driving easier to see what increase you had?
jamescartagena
08-24-2006, 03:19 PM
I use it for all three vehicles.
97 Ford F150 - 3 oz/10 gal
92 Saturn SL1 - Currently testing 3 oz/10 gal
03 Honda Odyssey - 2 oz/ 10 gal
All get about a 10% increase of fuel economy. I've started using it last year and have run through 2 1/2 gallons of it so far. Anyone who says it will hurt your engine I think either hasn't tried it or is listening to someone else. My truck has used most of the two gallons as I drove it the most until I got the Saturn. The wife drives the Honda so I put in acetone about every other tankful when I get around to it. All get a noticable increase in power as well. In my truck feels the most noticable, and the exhaust pipe no longer has any black soot in it. I wouldn't drive without it even if it didn't increase my mileage because the increase in power is that noticable to me.
SVOboy
08-24-2006, 04:21 PM
It matters that you got some good acetone and that you drive to save otherwise you dont' get an improvement - it allows you to get even better gas mileage with it that without it - it doesn't give you better gas mileage it allows you to get better mileage. I couldn't get past 46mpg until I used it now I get 50-55mpg.
This goes against the theory of acetone. If it does indeed aid vaporization so greatly it won't matter how you drive, because your fuel will get "burnt more completely" anyway.
zpiloto
08-24-2006, 06:16 PM
Hey I get 32mpg if I drive 80 on the highway with acetone - it doesn't help when you are burning it at 2.5 gallons an hour - it helps when you are burning 0.3 to 0.5 gallons per hour by making the injectors work better at low volume operation when they usually don't atomize the fuel properly.
I thought that the fuel pump provided the same amount of fuel pressure to the injectors no matter what the engine rpm is. The only difference would be the amount of pulsing that is requried to meet the fuel demand. Since the pressure is constant the amount of atomization would be the same, just less pulses.
Ted Hart
09-01-2006, 03:30 PM
I used it for a little more than a month last year which translates into about a 1000 miles and didn't see any change in FE before, during or after using the stuff.
-- Scott
Give a man a fish...and he will eat for a day. Teach a man to fish...and he will tell fish stories for the rest of his life!:D
JanGeo
09-01-2006, 04:35 PM
I thought that the fuel pump provided the same amount of fuel pressure to the injectors no matter what the engine rpm is. The only difference would be the amount of pulsing that is requried to meet the fuel demand. Since the pressure is constant the amount of atomization would be the same, just less pulses.
Yeah and the duration of the injector spray is varied to vary the amount of fuel injected but the spray during valve opening and closing during short pulses is not as good as when they run wide open. There is also fuel flow variations when the flow changes which effectively varies the pressure slightly.
Saw an intesting bit of info on Synlube site today apparently 1 gallon of gas requires 10,000 gallons of air to burn 14.7 to 1 ratio - that translates to a lot of air!
Coyote X
09-02-2006, 12:20 AM
I ran acetone for 4 months straight 3oz/10 gal ratio. My mpg did increase over 3 tanks 2-3mpg. I used up the small amount I had and never bothered getting any more after I ran out. The mpg never went down from not using it over the next 10 or so tanks of gas. I would say the acetone is a good injector and fuel system cleaner so it can help clean out the system and get it running properly. But once the fuel system is clean it doesn't help improve mileage over that. So I plan on picking up another quart of acetone and using it occasionally to help keep the fuel system clean but other than that I don't see it helping much.
n0rt0npr0
02-21-2008, 01:00 PM
I gotta disagree, and state the opposite. It allows those who P&G with hard throttling up to speed to see even greater results. But you have to have a newer o2 to go with its use(less than 30k). And anyone who has a heavy foot will also see better fuel mileage.
Hey I get 32mpg if I drive 80 on the highway with acetone - it doesn't help when you are burning it at 2.5 gallons an hour - it helps when you are burning 0.3 to 0.5 gallons per hour by making the injectors work better at low volume operation when they usually don't atomize the fuel properly.
VetteOwner
02-21-2008, 05:17 PM
I ran acetone for 4 months straight 3oz/10 gal ratio. My mpg did increase over 3 tanks 2-3mpg. I used up the small amount I had and never bothered getting any more after I ran out. The mpg never went down from not using it over the next 10 or so tanks of gas. I would say the acetone is a good injector and fuel system cleaner so it can help clean out the system and get it running properly. But once the fuel system is clean it doesn't help improve mileage over that. So I plan on picking up another quart of acetone and using it occasionally to help keep the fuel system clean but other than that I don't see it helping much.
that it does. and sometimes i think people get the placebo effect:p
i run half a can of seafoam thru the engine and the rest in the gas every oil change:thumbup:
slimreynolds
02-21-2008, 05:49 PM
I use 3 parts acetone, 1 part xylene, and 1 part lucas oil upper cylinder lubricant. I saw a 12% gain in the summer but little or no gain in the winter. I add 3 ozs of mixture to 10 gallons of gas. Works best in warmer conditions. Also really cleans out injectors and fuel system. My 2004 toyota matrix has 280, 000 miles and runs like it did at 60k.
gto78
02-21-2008, 09:05 PM
2 Test vehicles on round 1300 mile round trip. 1 2004 Toyota Camry V-6, 1 2001 Toyota Solara V-6. Both cars driven in tandem. Average highway speed 78 MPH using cruise control as often as practical. On the trip away from home the camry averaged 29.9 mpg, the Solara averaged 24 mpg. Both cars used 93 octane round trip. On the way home both vehicles used 3 oz acetone per 10 gal gasoline. The mileage home was 33.5 MPG camry, 27 MPG Solara. We only bought fuel at name brand gas stations which are less likely to already contain tons of oxygenates etc. in their fuel.
Our 98 explorer gets about 2 mpg increase as well.
kamesama980
02-22-2008, 03:15 PM
my 88 cressida had no appreciable results trend. I tried with everywhere from .5-4 oz/g
My Jeep showed no change in FE, just a better idle. I tried 2oz/10g and 4oz/10g
fowljesse
03-19-2008, 03:20 AM
My '93 Mazda MX-3 GS's both get about 3 more mpg with 2 3/4 oz. Acetone per 10 gal. gas. The one with a 1.8L V6 has had this added for over 2 years, and when I forget, or can't, it goes back down 3 mpg. the one with a 2.5L high compression (210 psi) engine got 30 mpg on 89 octane (1 mpg more than good 92 octane).
RoadWarrior
03-19-2008, 02:53 PM
I've tried acetone in both Wile-E and Marvin... I was doing alternate tanks on and off, ABABA.... on Wile-E I was getting some variation, but it was hard to tell if it was significant, my high tanks seemed to be a little higher and my lows didn't seem as low. On Marvin, I was getting more of a definite gain, 1-2mpg better. Which is a bigger gain around the 20mpg level than the 30mpg level. I kinda got out of using it because it was too much of a PITA for marginal gain on Wile-E and I had Marvin laid up..... then haven't gone back to it on Marvin, since his rings aren't the tightest in the world any more and began to be worried about it affecting the oil. So it seemed to do a best of 10% or so on Marvin, but Wile-E's figures seemed to suggest it was getting 5% or less.
I understand the comment about "driving to save" with it though. Wile-E, one has to drive fairly hard anyway, due to limited power, and speed required to merge safely, Marvin has power to spare, but you have to spare it to save gas. In both vehicles, it subjectively ran smoother and more responsively, when that happens one does have to be careful not to "have fun" and just accelerate excessively for the hell of it. Meaning that as with some other gas saving tips, it's also a potential performance gainer, and it works as long as you use it wisely and don't succumb to the power of the dark side.... even if they have cookies.
Jetta90GL
03-19-2008, 05:21 PM
I tried it in my 97 F250HD with no real increase in mpg. I tried various mixes and logged them all in excel to try to narrow down what mix worked best. I just gave it up cause I got tired of adding mixes to the tank. I think ford's EEC-IV cpu fights any mpg increase I try. The only guaranteed (fuel related) mpg boost that works for me is using 100% gasoline and not 10% ethanol. Thats worth 2 to 3 mpg in my truck.
RoadWarrior
03-19-2008, 05:47 PM
Yeah, same core ECU in Wile-E the Escort there. If I don't pick up MPG when the modded head goes back on it, then I'll start messing around with biasing the MAF a little to see if it's foolable.
acetone marty
03-20-2008, 11:22 PM
I use 3oz acetone, 3oz xylene, 1oz amsoil 100to1 2 stroke oil, 1oz megalene gas additive with a pcv trap and scangauge read 50.5 mpg on hwy at 100kmh.Thats a 10 to 12 mpg increase in my ford focus, just to compare i took out a 2008 ford focus today rated at 50 mpg [canadian] and my scangauge read 39.8 on the same stretch of road i tested my 2000 focus on this combination works wonders for me and my buddies. You guys in the u.s have problem finding pure acetone needs to be 99.4% pure the only place you can get that is at a sally beauty salon and some home depots.Your mileage will decrease with impure stuff or more than 3oz per 10 gallons.You can try adding more xylene to see if it helps some vehicles need more my friends 95 gm astro van needs 4oz per 10 gallons
fowljesse
03-21-2008, 10:59 PM
I should mention that I cruise at about 70 mph, and don't employ driving techniques as faithfully as most people here. Maybe Acetone makes more of a difference for us less hypermile minded. If I were more patient, I'm sure I could push my 30 mpg to 35 or more.
8307c4
03-22-2008, 03:25 AM
Vehicles used:
1995 D-2500 Slt Laramie
1988 Bmw 325ic
I don't think it does, the bmw's mpg got worse, the truck seemed to improve but it wasn't conclusive... Also don't forget to figure in the price of acetone, I paid nearly $10 a gallon for it so 3 ounces per 10 gallons adds 23.44 cents to every gallon!
Even if I see an improvement and at today's prices that adds 7% to the price of fuel, then I need to figure in my time so for myself to see an improvement that pays off I would have to see at least 15% improvement and I can honestly say I don't think I saw 10% if I saw that.
Adding a tonneau cover was more expensive initially but doing that gave me some figures to compare... My last tank's mpg on the truck was 11.88 compared to the usual 10.0 - 10.5 - 10.8 mpg, now I never saw over 11 with acetone.
And it was good acetone, 99% stuff from Sally's Beauty supply.
Hey I get 32mpg if I drive 80 on the highway with acetone - it doesn't help when you are burning it at 2.5 gallons an hour - it helps when you are burning 0.3 to 0.5 gallons per hour by making the injectors work better at low volume operation when they usually don't atomize the fuel properly.
Yes but now it's the driving that's saving the fuel, not the acetone.
Try driving like that without acetone :)
acetone marty
03-22-2008, 11:33 AM
I can buy my acetone in canada for $7.89 per litre or 1000mls, i add to my focus 100mls per fill or 3.2 ozs= 78.9 cents. xylene costs $6.50 per litre i add 100mls of that=65.0 cents. amsoil syn 2 stroke oil costs $8.99 a litre i add 1oz=.29 cents. megalene gas additive costs $ 8.50 per 250ml i add 10ml= .34 cents all per 10 u.s gallons. total cost per fillup=$2.06 per 10 gallons.I have gained 12 mpg gallon with this combo according to my scangauge 50.5 versus 38 at the start.On a tank of fuel i can go 120 miles further at $5.40 a gallon here in northern b.c canada,at 50.5 mpg i am saving $ 12.83 a tank -$ 2.03 for the additives i still save $ 10.80 per tank, at 3 fills per month =$389 saving per year and i havent even put on all the rest of my gas saving devices yet.
8307c4
03-23-2008, 04:50 AM
I can buy my acetone in canada for $7.89 per litre
Wow that's almost $30 a gallon, shoot no, mine's way cheaper when there's 3.785 liters in one gallon it costs me 10 bucks for almost 4 liters and still it's not cheaper in terms of economy.
This is the problem: dumping 3 ounces of that Canadian acetone is costing another 70 cents, say times 10 gallons of fuel that's 30 ounces so 7 dollars.
Then we have to add all the rest of the additives and it wouldn't surprise me if you're not dumping an extra $20 into your tank in this fashion.
So the question I keep throwing around is, does this $20 pay off in the savings, or wouldn't it be as cheap to just put another $20 worth of fuel in the tank and be done with it?
Lets assume 40mpg straight fuel, 10 gallons, $5 a gallon.
Hmmm that's $50 but here we add another $20 so we get 14 gallons x 40 =
560 miles for $70
So then we take the other formula, 10 gallons, 50 mpg, $50 for fuel + $20 for additives, I'll give you the mileage here for the extra ounces of additives which is roughly a quart so 10.25 x 50 =
512.5 miles for $70
What do we want, 40mpg, pay $70 and go 560 miles...
Or 50mpg, pay $70 and only go 512.5 miles...
That's the whole point of the exercise is fuel economy.
Miles per gallon is just that, but Fuel economy is miles for the dollar, and if it costs more to go the same distance then it is not feasible economically speaking.
I did want to add, one-time expenses are not calculated the exact same way and in that sense a one-time expense can be a lot higher but it also has to be figured (over the expected life of the car vs. Blue book value and maybe one or two other things).
So unfortunately we have to do the math, or it doesn't work.
acetone marty
03-23-2008, 11:20 AM
To fill my tank on my ford focus is only 10 u.s gallons or 37.8 litres.It holds 45 litres completly empty it only costs me $2.03 for all the additives i add per tank full,10 gallons u.s or 37.8 litres, not per gallon, thats where youre not seeing the savings. If it did cost me $20.30 per 10 gallons for the additives there is no way it would pay for itself. After all is said and done with the increase in mileage i get per tank i am saving $10.80 in my pocket that allows me to get 2 gallons free next fill.There is no guessing on what theses additives can do my scangauge tells it all. I will be testing this combo on my 22ft bayliner trophy with 150 hp merc 2 stroke. I bought a floscan fuel meter and will be doing some testing soon.
trollbait
03-31-2008, 08:17 AM
There may have been a slight increase when I tried it, but it could have been to other variables. Even if, it wasn't enough to warrant the cost and hassle.
On the other hand, the v-6's in the Ranger are prone to pinginess, and I've noticed it on the steep hills. I'll try in again during hotter weather to see how it works as an octane booster. I also plan on trying a higher octane sometime during the summer.
jd1828
03-31-2008, 04:10 PM
I use to use acetone in a 96 eagle talon tsi. No real difference in mpg but one of the rubber fuel lines did start leaking after a year.
JanGeo
03-31-2008, 05:35 PM
Vehicles used:
1995 D-2500 Slt Laramie
1988 Bmw 325ic
I don't think it does, the bmw's mpg got worse, the truck seemed to improve but it wasn't conclusive... Also don't forget to figure in the price of acetone, I paid nearly $10 a gallon for it so 3 ounces per 10 gallons adds 23.44 cents to every gallon!
Check your math . . . it adds 2.344 cents per gallon . . . 23.44 cents per TEN gallons! Now it is not so bad HUH? Takes about a 1% mileage improvement to break even.
And driving 80 MPH without Acetone would produce a lower mileage but there is no place to drive that fast around here. THere are some xB owners that do drive that fast and get in the high TEENS for MPG.
JanGeo
05-15-2008, 12:51 PM
Hey I had a friend with a Professional discount get me a gallon at Sally's - looking forward to the next filling to add some of the new Acetone to see if it works any better than the Ace brand I have been using.
Used home center acetone for most of a year in the last car. Nothing out of the ordinary. But the car really never reacted to anything. Got a new car, and the first tank with acetone dropped from 12.3 to 10.7. Not much of an increase to me. I will drive this current tank down, and maybe try it again. I was actually being nice to the car 98% of the time. Only hit boost twice.
bowtieguy
05-15-2008, 07:19 PM
my days of using acetone are likely numbered. E10 finally has made its way to florida. my last real jump in FE using it was just before the "contains up to 10% ethanol" sign was placed at my favorite filling station.
it must be true that ethanol negates the affects of acetone. that's what i'm experiencing anyway.
ZugyNA
05-16-2008, 08:58 AM
It is said...and is whispered in the back alleys...that isopropyl at about the same % as acetone works even with the ethanol. I tried 4-5 oz of 91% (9% water) and saw no gain...but had other stuff happening...did have more power though. Need to use a top oil though to protect the fuel pump.
I'd use 2-3 oz per 10 G if I tried it again. I'd probably more likely try 24 oz cheap canola oil and 3 oz iso per 10 G. Some claim good mpg gains and not a lot of smoke...maybe cause the canola acts as much as a fuel as it does a lube?
note: this is what I'd try...your intentions may be different...:cool:
8307c4
05-16-2008, 11:00 AM
Check your math . . . it adds 2.344 cents per gallon . . . 23.44 cents per TEN gallons! Now it is not so bad HUH? Takes about a 1% mileage improvement to break even.
And driving 80 MPH without Acetone would produce a lower mileage but there is no place to drive that fast around here. THere are some xB owners that do drive that fast and get in the high TEENS for MPG.
You are correct I did mess that up, but now a gallon of acetone is $16 :p
So almost 4 cents a gallon, 1% yeah...
All right but the more folks dump acetone in the tank the higher acetone goes.
We just don't have a million barrels of acetone a day to go around.
90accord
05-20-2008, 05:03 PM
I have a 1990 accord ex 4 dr w/5spd tranny with no 3rd gear (its gone!!!). The best mpg I could get was 25 mpg with mix driving. That's open Freeway in the morning and traffic in the afternoon going home from work. I drive 55-60 in the mornings and in traffic (stop and go) in afternoons. 2 days after I added a 3oz acetone/10 gal. Gas mix I got a wooping 29.17 mpg. My gas cost went from $9.19 a day to $6.83 a day. I celebrated and bought me a 16oz beer to drink at home!!! that's the price differance I save a day now!!! Thanks yall!!!
Max
bkrell
05-20-2008, 05:52 PM
Over at bitog we've had a lot of people try acetone in various ratios at least as far back as the Katrina aftermath. I can think of ONE person who's seen any sustained increase in FE.
Big Dave
05-20-2008, 07:18 PM
Snake oil man, snake oil.
I tried a couple of quarts of it 2, 3, and 4 oz to 10 gallons and...nothing.
Like two-stroke oil, acetone is just wishful thinking.
12% improvement? I'm calling BS on that.
bkrell
05-20-2008, 07:50 PM
I've never heard of people using 2 stroke for FE, just upper cylinder lubricity.... But I don't doubt people trying it.....
RoadWarrior
05-28-2008, 06:14 PM
Well the idea is that some sort of oil helps stop acetone or other solvents killing your fuel pump from lack of lubricity.
I've just stuck 2oz of Evinrude OMC low carbon TC-W3 and 5oz of acetone in my full tank for a retry. (15 gal tank)
I wasn't bothering because we are supposedly getting ethanol now, but last time I was at my fave gas station I looked all over the pumps and couldn't see the warning sticker, so thought I'd give it a go again. Used to be worth ~2mpg in marvin.
Doesn't so far seem to have got that same smoothness I remember before, but it's pulling up grades okay. Gonna try and remember to fill up before I do the weekend city thrashing.
bkrell
05-28-2008, 09:14 PM
But GASOLINE is a solvent. What does it matter if you put acetone in? Many, if not most after market injector/fuel system cleaners have acetone or MEK in them.
JanGeo
05-28-2008, 09:48 PM
The Torco GP-7 two stroke lube has PIB chemical that helps the gas burn better as well as provide some lubrication and only a very small amount is needed for it to be effective.
I just put my first 3 oz of Sally's Acetone in my xB after almost a gallon of Ace Acetone and have not driven much yet but I did see a record high mileage trip from Home to Office the other night.
RoadWarrior
05-31-2008, 10:35 PM
Hmmm, inconclusive... matched my best tanks, which is ~5% higher than average. But, the gas I was running is from the "wrong" pump, the ones I always try to avoid, but couldn't due to it being busy, all my low tanks are off those pumps, and my high tanks are off the "good" pumps, so it could be as high as 10%, or it could be 0 as it's within normal variation.